Judge Calls Immigration Officials Decision Beyond Cruel

Free Internet Press operates on your donations.

Why Donate?

No advertisements. No "donate now" reminders. Unlimited access to the Free Internet Press News Archives. Unlimited access to the Free Internet Press News Aggregator. You're supporting a great cause, getting the uncensored news out on current events to the world! Why not? It's only $3.00 a month.

The ruling says a detainee who later died of penile cancer was denied a biopsy of a lesion though several doctors said the procedure was urgently needed. His family will be allowed to seek damages.

In a stinging ruling, a Los Angeles federal judge said immigration officials' alleged decision to withhold a critical medical test and other treatment from a detainee who later died of cancer was "beyond cruel and unusual" punishment.

The decision from U.S. District Judge Dean Pregerson allows the family of Francisco Castaneda to seek financial damages from the government.

Castaneda, who suffered from penile cancer, died Feb. 16. Before his release from custody last year, the government had refused for 11 months to authorize a biopsy for a growing lesion, even though voluminous government records showed that several doctors said the test was urgently needed, given Castaneda's condition and a family history of cancer, said Pregerson.

Yet rather than test and treat Castaneda, government officials told him to be patient and prescribed antihistamines, ibuprofen and extra boxer shorts, the judge wrote in a decision released late Tuesday. In summary, the judge wrote, the care provided to Castaneda "can be characterized by one word: nothing."

Pregerson blasted public health officials' "attempt to sidestep responsibility for what appears to be ... one of the most, if not the most, egregious" violations of the constitutional prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment that "the court has ever encountered."

At this stage of the proceedings, "the only question is whether" the plaintiffs' allegations, if true, show that government officials "were deliberately indifferent to his condition. The court finds that they do," said Pregerson.

"Everyone knows that cancer is often deadly. Everyone knows that early diagnosis and treatment often saves lives," the judge wrote. The government's own records, he emphasized, "bespeak of conduct that transcends negligence by miles. It bespeaks of conduct that, if true, should be taught to every law student as conduct for which the moniker 'cruel' is inadequate," Pregerson concluded in permitting the case to move forward.

Conal Doyle, an Oakland attorney who is co-counsel for Castaneda's family members, said the Salvadoran immigrant spent eight months in custody on a charge of possession of methamphetamine with intent to sell, then was transferred to immigration custody because he did not have legal residency.

He first informed the Immigration and Customs Enforcement medical staff at the San Diego Correctional Facility on March 27, 2006, that "a lesion on his penis was becoming painful and growing," the judge wrote. The next day, a physician assistant at the facility examined Castaneda and issued a treatment plan calling for a consultation with a urologist "ASAP" and a request for a biopsy, according to government records cited by the judge.

Over the next 11 months, several doctors, with increasing urgency, made the same recommendations. For example, after conducting an examination June 7, 2006, Dr. John Wilkinson, an oncologist, wrote a report saying he strongly agreed that Castaneda had an urgent need for a biopsy and an assessment by a urologist because he might have "penile cancer. ... In this extremely delicate area ... there can be considerable morbidity from even benign lesions which are not promptly treated."

That same day, Pregerson said, Dr. Esther Hui of the Division of Immigration Health Services acknowledged Castaneda's condition but said the government would not admit him to a hospital because her agency considered a biopsy "an elective outpatient procedure."

Pregerson, who became a federal judge in 1996, said evidence presented by the plaintiffs suggested that Hui, one of the defendants, characterized the surgery as elective so the federal government would not to have to provide or pay for it.

In February 2007, after the American Civil Liberties Union intervened, a biopsy was finally scheduled. A few days before the procedure, however, Castaneda was abruptly released, the judge wrote. He went to the emergency room of Harbor-UCLA Medical Center and was diagnosed with metastatic squamous cell carcinoma. His penis was eventually amputated, and chemotherapy ultimately proved unsuccessful.

Four months before he died, Castaneda testified at a hearing held by the U.S. House Judiciary Subcommittee on Immigration, Citizenship, Refugees, Border Security and International Law, as his teenage daughter listened.

"Mr. Castaneda's case was just outrageous," U.S. Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-San Jose), chairwoman of the subcommittee, said in an interview Tuesday.

Lofgren said one of the things she found most troubling was that "bureaucrats" at Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in Washington, D.C., have the power to overrule recommendations of doctors who have actually seen the medical problems of detainees. "That is a recipe for disaster," she said.

Lori Haley, an ICE spokeswoman from Laguna Niguel, said in an e-mail that she could not comment on the Castaneda case but that the agency spent nearly $100 million on medical, dental and psychiatric care for detainees in fiscal 2007.

The government had argued that its employees were immune from this lawsuit. A spokesman for the U.S. attorney's office said the Justice Department might appeal Pregerson's ruling.

Last year, the U.S. Government Accountability Office issued a report on medical care at immigration detention facilities that said officials at some of the sites "cited difficulties in obtaining approval for outside medical and mental health care as ... presenting problems in caring for detainees."

Doyle said Castaneda's death "would have been prevented by the exercise of basic human decency."

Loyola Law School professor Laurie Levenson said the decision was legally significant and factually compelling. "This was not a detainee with a hangnail," she said. "You should not have to have your penis fall off to get medical treatment from the government."

Intellpuke: You can read this article by Los Angeles Times staff writer Henry Weinstein, reporting from Los Angeles, California, in context here: www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-me-cruel13mar13,1,1951476.story

According to medical statistics, two thirds of the adult male, in penile erection, has different severity of the phenomenon of bending, but only about 30 percent of men, stand is a complete state, and the bending direction, bend upward, some downward bending, bending some left, some right bend, and some will be under upward or both the left or right bending and bending, and bending the location in the front of the penis, middle or back-end have possible. Congenital penile curvature and masturbation (masturbation) no relationship, nor is it because too wear pants or wearing trousers when the penis not smiling, it is impossible to use in wearing trousers, will be placed in the penis curved in the opposite direction to correct; At present there is insufficient scientific evidence to show that Pazhao sleep and penile curvature in any way. Congenital penile curvature, mainly because of the male penis with dual the corpus cavernosum, but around the side of the cavernous, in adolescence, not growing as fast, even with the side of the cavernous, nor certainly, down, left and right on the development of exactly the same, so will the size and length of a cavernous case. Inclusive of the corpus cavernosum penis tunica albuginea have great flexibility, the penis was soft-Consumers, see

Yizhuang, a minority of the there will be pain in patients with the impression that if the difficulties of sexual intercourse when they need treatment. In the clinic, there are also bending male penis, forced sex because of improper tunica albuginea of the penis caused by burst, and need immediate surgical repair, or likely to cause erectile difficulties in the future, not completely, or after erection, and more bending . Bending to the treatment of congenital penile surgery, there is no any kind of oral or injectable drugs available to treat penile curvature, more than 90 percent of cosmetic surgery patients who were available after the marked improvement. To the timing of surgical treatment for more than 18 years, because, if the development has not yet completed the penis, surgery may be an overkill, or easily relapse. Surgical method is based on the latest Jiechangbuduan bend or straight, surgery could be in the corpus cavernosum of water or saline infusion of prostaglandin e1 such as vasodilators, causing erection of the penis in order to master the surgical correction angle. Cause penile curvature of the reasons, in addition to inherent differences in the development of Penis, penis trauma, pelvic fracture, may cause penile curvature. And penile curvature of more than 90 degrees above, the merger has to worry about whether the situation hypospadias. Middle-aged and older men, if bending penis every day, we should worry about is not Pironi s disease, This is an exact cause of the penis tunica albuginea fibrosis, must be treated immediately, to avoid more bending penis.

Additional information :

From freeinternetpress.com:
Since your penis is a muscle, it needs regular exercise to maintain the flow of blood in and out of penis. If you take penis exercise with penis stretcher.
Matters of Size Natural Penis Enlargement uses a unique 5 Phase program to teach you the power of the Natural Penis Enlargement Exercises.
We have researched and complied the top 5 penis enlargement exercise program as well as provide all the information you need to know about penis exercises.
Sizepro, sizepro, size pro, male enhancement, penis enlargement, penis pills. penis enlargement exercise, penis enlargement.
Know penis enlargement exercises and techniques. Also read other useful.
As you may have noticed there are numerous natural penis enlargement products around. Pills, exercises, pumps, weights, creams, patches, herbal.
Pimp My Size is a website about penis enlargement using natural penis enlargement systems like penis exercises, jelquin, herbal pills, penis enlargement.
Exercises are one of the most effective, and fastest ways to add inches to your penis. However, you cannot use any technique.